It's been brought to my attention that before in order to get an Avatar the full 200 pixels length to match our rank images you had to upload your picture to Photobucket/ImageShack etc. and couldn't just upload the image from your computer.

So I think I've fixed the problem, so try it out by all means

If it still doesn't work let me know and I can tweak the settings some more or at least set your avatar myself. That is if you want one 200 pixels long anyway.